Skip to main content

Hidden Email Forwarding Rules: The Quiet Way Attackers Keep Reading Your Mail

A hidden mailbox forwarding rule can let an attacker keep receiving copies of selected business emails after they have gained access to an account. In Microsoft 365, forwarding can be set in more than one place, so changing a password alone may not stop it.

What is a mailbox forwarding rule?

Email forwarding sends a copy of a message received by one mailbox to another address. It is a normal feature: someone might forward mail to a colleague while on leave, for example. It becomes a security issue when an attacker uses it to quietly collect messages from a compromised account.

Microsoft describes automatic forwarding as a way attackers may access email without the account holder realising. They may target messages about invoices, payments or particular suppliers, rather than copy every message. This means the mailbox can appear to work as usual: messages still arrive, and the user may not notice anything missing.

Forwarding is one way an attacker can maintain access during a business email compromise (BEC). If a mailbox contains payment instructions or supplier correspondence, the attacker may use what they learn to support a payment redirection attempt. See our guide to payment redirection fraud.

Where forwarding can be configured in Microsoft 365

There are several mechanisms to check. The names and locations matter because looking at one setting does not rule out forwarding elsewhere.

1. Organisation-wide mail-flow rules

An administrator can create a mail-flow rule, also called a transport rule, in the Exchange admin centre (EAC). A rule can apply to messages across the organisation or to a defined group, and can redirect or forward messages according to its conditions.

A malicious or mistaken rule here may affect more than one mailbox. In the EAC, check Mail flow > Rules for rules that redirect messages, add recipients or forward mail externally. Confirm that each rule has a clear business purpose and an authorised owner.

2. Forwarding set on an individual mailbox

An administrator can enable forwarding directly on a mailbox. This is sometimes called SMTP forwarding. Depending on the setting, a copy may stay in the original mailbox, or messages may be forwarded without being delivered there.

In the EAC, go to Recipients > Mailboxes, select the mailbox, then open Manage mail flow settings > Email forwarding. Check both whether forwarding is enabled and where messages are being sent.

3. Outlook inbox rules

A user can create rules in Outlook or Outlook on the web to forward, redirect, move or otherwise process incoming mail. Rules may apply to every message or only to those that match conditions.

For example, a rule could forward messages containing “invoice”, “bank details” or a particular supplier’s name. A selective rule can be harder to spot than one forwarding every message, because the user continues to receive most email normally.

Users can also set up forwarding themselves, sometimes accidentally. Someone leaving a job might forward work messages to a personal address for convenience. That can expose company information and should be addressed through offboarding and mailbox checks.

How to audit forwarding in Microsoft 365

Start with organisation-level reporting, then inspect the rules and settings themselves. Microsoft’s Auto-forwarded messages report in the new EAC can show external automatic forwarding, including the forwarding type, user, recipient domain and first-forward date. It is a useful way to identify accounts or destinations to investigate; it does not replace checking the underlying settings.

For a practical review:

  1. Check the Auto-forwarded messages report. Look for unfamiliar users, external recipient domains and forwarding you cannot tie to an approved business need. Adjust the date range if the default view does not cover the period you need.
  2. Review mail-flow rules. In the EAC, open Mail flow > Rules. Pay attention to rules that redirect or forward messages, especially to external addresses or only under unusual conditions.
  3. Inspect mailbox forwarding settings. Go to Recipients > Mailboxes, select each relevant mailbox and check Manage mail flow settings > Email forwarding.
  4. Review the user’s Outlook rules. In Outlook on the web or new Outlook, open Settings > Mail > Rules and look for rules that forward, redirect, delete or move messages. Check Mail > Forwarding as well.

Outlook’s rules page is useful for checking rules a user can see, but it is not a complete security audit. Some rules may be hidden or require administrator tools to inspect. Microsoft’s instructions for responding to a compromised account include checking hidden inbox rules with Exchange Online PowerShell. If you suspect an account has been compromised, ask your Microsoft 365 administrator or IT provider to check all forwarding methods, not only the settings visible in Outlook.

A rule with an unfamiliar name is not proof of an attack. Check what it does, who created it and whether there is a legitimate business reason. The destination address and the messages selected by the rule are often more revealing than its name.

Why a password reset may not be enough

A password reset changes the account’s password; it does not necessarily remove a forwarding rule already stored in the mailbox or organisation settings. So the rule may continue to copy messages even after the user can sign in with a new password.

A password reset may also leave other access paths to investigate. If an attacker has an active session, an administrator may need to revoke sessions as part of the response. Check the sign-in logs for unfamiliar locations, devices or activity around the time the rule appeared. Review registered MFA methods and remove any the user does not recognise.

Also check for unauthorised delegated mailbox access, suspicious application permissions and changes to other account settings. Microsoft’s guide to responding to a compromised cloud email account covers these investigation steps.

If you find a suspicious rule

Treat an unknown forwarding destination as a possible sign that the account or its administration has been compromised.

  • Record what you found, including the destination, conditions and rule name. This information can help establish what was exposed and when.
  • Disable or remove the rule and any unauthorised mailbox forwarding or mail-flow rule. If you are unsure whether a rule is legitimate, confirm its purpose with the owner before removing it.
  • Secure the account. Reset the password, revoke active sessions and check that MFA is enabled and registered methods belong to the user.
  • Review sign-in and audit activity around the time the rule was created or changed. Look for other accounts or administrator settings that may also have been affected.
  • Check what the rule could have exposed. If it captured invoice or bank-detail conversations, verify recent payment instructions with suppliers using a known phone number, not contact details in a suspect email.

If the mailbox may have been used to request payments or change bank details, follow your organisation’s incident process and contact your bank promptly if money has been sent. Our article on payment redirection fraud explains the checks to take.

A hypothetical example

Imagine an accountancy practice in Hampshire where an employee’s Microsoft 365 account is compromised after a reused password is exposed. The attacker creates an inbox rule that forwards only messages containing “invoice” or “bank details” to an outside address.

The employee continues to receive ordinary mail and sees no obvious change. When a supplier later emails about a payment, the attacker can read the exchange and may attempt to influence where the money is sent. This is a hypothetical example, not a BITSmart customer case.

The rule would not prove that a payment had been redirected. It would be a reason to investigate the account, review relevant correspondence and verify any payment changes independently.

Reduce the chance of hidden forwarding

For a Microsoft 365 tenant, useful controls include:

  • Require MFA for user accounts, especially administrators. Our articles explain MFA for cloud apps and how different MFA methods compare.
  • Use Conditional Access where your Microsoft 365 licensing and configuration support it. Policies can set conditions for sign-in, such as requiring MFA in specified circumstances.
  • Block automatic external forwarding by default using the relevant outbound spam policy, then make carefully controlled exceptions for approved business needs. Microsoft explains the options in its guidance on controlling automatic external email forwarding. Test the policy against legitimate workflows before applying it, as external forwarding may be used for valid reasons.
  • Alert on new or changed forwarding rules. Alerts are useful only if they are sent to someone who can review them and act. Check which Microsoft 365 security and monitoring features are available in your tenant.
  • Include mailbox forwarding in joiner, mover and leaver checks. Review rules and forwarding settings when someone changes role or leaves, and confirm that any approved forwarding has an owner and an end date.

Book a Call

BITSmart can audit a Microsoft 365 tenant for forwarding rules, review mailbox and mail-flow settings, set tenant-level controls and monitor for new rules. Our work includes managed IT support, cybersecurity and real-time system monitoring, alongside network infrastructure management and router/firewall setting reviews.

If you want to review how forwarding is handled in your Microsoft 365 environment, Book a Call with BITSmart.

Tony Edwards, Chief Everything Officer at BITSmart
Tony Edwards

BITSmart’s Chief Everything Officer. Tony helps small businesses across Hampshire keep their IT secure and explained in plain English.

Is your Microsoft 365 set up securely?

Book a free 30-minute call and get an honest view of where you stand.

You might also like

Want an honest view of your IT security

Book a free 30-minute call and we’ll tell you where you stand.